7 Best Loyalty Software in 2026, Compared
Compare the 7 best loyalty software for online stores, shops and restaurants on points, VIP tiers, referrals, POS links and real cost, checked on vendor pages.
We compare pricing pages, documentation and public reviews. We never accept payment for rankings.

Key takeaways
- Smile.io is the easiest start for online stores: free up to 200 orders a month, then Essential at $15 a month.
- Yotpo and LoyaltyLion both start paid plans at $199 a month; Yotpo pairs with its reviews suite, while LoyaltyLion includes Klaviyo flows and onboarding.
- Marsello is the pick for physical retail that wants loyalty tied to the POS, from $60 a month per site in USD, with no contract.
- Restaurants and shops already on Square, Toast or SpotOn should price the POS's own loyalty before adding a separate app.
On this page
Quick comparison
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smile.io | Small and mid-sized online stores that want points, referrals and VIP tiers with a free start | Free; $15/mo | Yes (200 orders/mo) |
| Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals | Online stores already using Yotpo reviews that want reviews to earn loyalty points | Free; Pro $199/mo | Yes (free plan) |
| LoyaltyLion | Growing Shopify brands that want a done-for-you loyalty launch with Klaviyo email flows | $199/mo (500 orders) | Free for small stores; 14-day trial |
| Marsello | Physical retailers that want loyalty, wallet passes and reviews tied to their POS and online store | $60/mo per site | No (14-day trial) |
| Square | Small shops and cafes on Square that want loyalty inside the POS they already use | Free POS; Plus $49/mo per location | Yes (Free plan) |
| SpotOn | Restaurants that want loyalty included with the POS rather than bought as an add-on | $0/station (All-In) | Yes (All-In $0) |
| Toast | Restaurants already on Toast that want loyalty tied to every check | $69/mo + loyalty add-on | Yes ($0 Starter Kit) |
Make one of these tools?
We re-check this list every quarter. Send a correction, request a review, or ask about a clearly labeled sponsored spot.
Request a listingThe best loyalty software
Smile.io
Best for: Small and mid-sized online stores that want points, referrals and VIP tiers with a free start
Smile.io is the loyalty app most small online stores try first, and the free plan is why: points, referrals, discount and free-shipping rewards, full branding and multi-language support for up to 200 orders a month. Essential at $15 a month raises the limit to 500 orders and adds free product rewards, a dedicated loyalty page, on-site nudges and Shopify Flow actions.
The ladder climbs by order volume: Standard costs $79 a month for 1,000 orders and Growth $199 for 2,500, with $20 per 100 extra orders. VIP tiers only arrive on Growth, and the free plan has no integrations or analytics pages, so most serious stores end up on Standard or above.
What we like
- Free plan includes points, referrals and full branding for up to 200 orders a month
- Essential at $15 a month is the cheapest paid loyalty plan in this list
- Clear order-based ladder up to Growth with VIP tiers at $199 a month
Watch out for
- The free plan has no integrations, no loyalty page and no analytics pages
- VIP program waits for Growth at $199 a month
- Overage charges apply above each plan's order limit on Growth and Smile Plus
Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals
Best for: Online stores already using Yotpo reviews that want reviews to earn loyalty points
Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals runs points and a real referral program on a free plan for stores with up to 100 orders a month, with more than 20 ready-made campaigns, including goal-spend and social engagement rewards. Its distinct advantage is the suite: paired with Yotpo Reviews, verified reviews can earn loyalty points without another integration.
Pro costs $199 a month for up to 500 orders and adds birthday rewards, social sharing rewards and advanced campaigns, with per-order charges above 500. There is nothing between free and $199, and VIP tiers and advanced segmentation wait for the custom-quoted Premium plan.
What we like
- The only free plan here that runs a real referral program — points and referrals at $0
- More than 20 out-of-the-box campaigns, including goal spend and social engagement
- Pairs with Yotpo Reviews, so verified reviews can earn loyalty points in one suite
- VIP tiers, smart segments and advanced analytics on the higher plans
Watch out for
- A large jump from the free plan to Pro at $199/month, with nothing in between
- Pro adds per-order charges above 500 orders a month, so the bill grows with volume
- VIP tiers and advanced segmentation wait for the custom-quoted Premium plan
LoyaltyLion
Best for: Growing Shopify brands that want a done-for-you loyalty launch with Klaviyo email flows
LoyaltyLion is built for brands that want the program set up for them. Classic includes a branded loyalty page built by the LoyaltyLion team, pre-built earning rules, points, vouchers and referrals, single-location Shopify POS, and a Klaviyo integration with ready-to-use email flows, plus analytics for retention, ROI, customer lifetime value and RFM segments.
Classic costs $199 a month for 500 orders. VIP tiers, Loyalty Pass and receipt upload are add-ons on Classic, while Advanced and Plus are priced by order volume with no published figure. Its FAQ recommends a free plan for stores processing 400 or fewer orders a month, and a 14-day trial runs through the Shopify App Store.
What we like
- Classic includes a branded loyalty page built for you and dedicated onboarding
- Klaviyo integration with ready-to-use email flows on the entry paid plan
- Retention, ROI, CLV and RFM analytics included from Classic
Watch out for
- VIP tiers are an add-on on Classic and included only from Advanced
- Advanced and Plus are custom-priced by order volume
- Stores that exceed their order threshold by more than 25% over three months are asked to review their plan
Marsello
Best for: Physical retailers that want loyalty, wallet passes and reviews tied to their POS and online store
Marsello is built for shops with a till as well as a website. Loyalty Launch connects to POS and ecommerce systems, so a customer earns the same points in store and online, and includes a customer portal, Apple and Google Wallet passes, RFM segmentation, basic referrals and feedback surveys. There are no contracts and no cancellation fee.
Launch costs $60 a month per site in USD, and Accelerate at $120 a month per site adds VIP tiers, points expiry, points promotions, Klaviyo sync and a Google Review Manager. Email marketing starts at $15 per 1,000 customers and SMS at $0.028 a credit as add-ons, and Lightspeed users get separate custom pricing.
What we like
- Works with POS and ecommerce, so in-store and online purchases earn the same points
- Apple and Google Wallet passes and a customer portal on the entry plan
- No contracts and no cancellation fee
Watch out for
- VIP tiers, points expiry and custom earn options need Accelerate at $120 a month per site
- Email marketing and SMS are billed separately as add-ons
- Each additional site adds the full per-site fee
Square
Best for: Small shops and cafes on Square that want loyalty inside the POS they already use
For a business that already takes payments on Square, the simplest loyalty program is the one built into the checkout, with customer data already in the POS and no separate app to sync. Square's Free plan covers the POS, item library, invoicing and bookings with no monthly fee, only processing at 2.6% plus 15 cents per in-person sale.
Plus, at $49 a month per location, adds loyalty and marketing alongside purchase orders, barcode labels and cost-of-goods reports, and there are no contracts. The trade-off is depth: it suits a points-for-visits program, not VIP tiers or omnichannel referral campaigns.
What we like
- Loyalty runs inside the checkout, with customer data already in the POS and no separate app to sync
- Plus at $49 a month per location adds loyalty and marketing to the POS you already use
- Tap to Pay on iPhone and Android takes cards with no reader, and hardware starts at $59 for a reader
- No contracts: cancel or switch plans at any time
Watch out for
- Free plan charges 2.6% + 15¢ per in-person sale, which costs more than interchange-plus pricing at high volume
- Suits a simple points-for-visits program, not VIP tiers or omnichannel referral campaigns
SpotOn
Best for: Restaurants that want loyalty included with the POS rather than bought as an add-on
SpotOn is the restaurant POS in this list that bundles loyalty rather than selling it separately. The All-In plan costs $0 per station with hardware, reservations, waitlist and loyalty included, and G2 reviewers rate it 4.4 out of 5, praising support most. Commission-free online ordering runs through SpotOn Order.
The $0 plan needs a two-year minimum term and charges the highest processing rate in its category, 2.79% plus 20 cents. POS Essentials costs $55 a station a month, month to month, with a lower card rate, and the Core Bundle adds online ordering and marketing tools for $50 a month plus 0.20% of card volume, capped at $200.
What we like
- Highest G2 score in this list at 4.4/5, with reviewers praising support most
- All-In at $0/station includes hardware, reservations, waitlist and loyalty
- POS Essentials at $55/station is month-to-month, with the lower 2.45% + 15c card rate
- Commission-free online ordering through SpotOn Order and the GoTo Place app
Watch out for
- The $0 All-In plan needs a two-year minimum term and charges the highest processing rate here
- Hardware is purchased outright on the month-to-month Essentials plan
- The Core Bundle add-on grows with card volume, up to $250/month at high volume
Toast
Best for: Restaurants already on Toast that want loyalty tied to every check
Toast is the restaurant POS other systems are measured against, and its loyalty add-on attaches rewards to the same checks, online orders and guest records the POS already holds. For a restaurant committed to Toast, adding its loyalty and marketing tools avoids syncing a separate app and keeps guest data in one place.
The Point of Sale plan costs $69 a month, with a $0 Starter Kit at a higher processing rate. Loyalty, gift cards, online ordering and email marketing are all paid add-ons, so the real bill runs well above $69. Hardware is Toast-only and contracts typically run two years.
What we like
- Built only for restaurants: menu, coursing, handheld ordering, kitchen display and online ordering in one stack
- The $0 Starter Kit lets a new restaurant start with no monthly software fee
- Point of Sale at $69/month pairs core POS with 2.49% + 15c card-present processing
- Largest restaurant POS install base in the US, so staff often already know it
Watch out for
- Online ordering, loyalty, gift cards and the kitchen display are paid add-ons, so the real bill runs well above $69/month
- Hardware is Toast-only — you cannot bring your own terminals
- Contracts typically run two years, and you must use Toast for payment processing
The best loyalty software turns one-time buyers into regulars by rewarding the behaviour you want: another order, a referral, a review or a birthday visit. We compared seven tools across online-store loyalty apps, omnichannel retail loyalty and the programs built into restaurant and retail POS systems, and every price below comes from the vendor's own pricing page as checked in November 2026.
How to choose the best loyalty software
- Start where your customers buy. Online-only stores need a Shopify-style app; shops and restaurants need loyalty that works at the till.
- Check the order meter. Smile.io, Yotpo and LoyaltyLion all price by monthly orders, so a busy season can move you up a tier.
- Decide if you need VIP tiers. Tiers cost more everywhere: Growth on Smile.io, Premium on Yotpo, Advanced on LoyaltyLion and Accelerate on Marsello.
- Connect it to your email and SMS. A loyalty program nobody hears about does nothing, so check the Klaviyo or built-in marketing link.
- Model the reward cost. Decide what a point is worth and what share of revenue you will give back before you launch.
- Avoid lock-in where you can. Marsello has no contract, while SpotOn's $0 plan and Toast typically run two years.
A loyalty program keeps the customers you already have; search brings new ones in the first place. If you need more first-time buyers to reward, our monthly SEO service works on that, and our guide to referral marketing software covers turning loyal customers into a source of new ones.
Loyalty software pricing: what you will actually pay
Take an online store doing 450 orders a month. Smile.io's free plan stops at 200 orders, so it needs Essential at $15 a month, $180 a year, which covers up to 500 orders. Yotpo's free plan stops at 100 orders, so it needs Pro at $199 a month, $2,388 a year, and LoyaltyLion Classic also costs $199 a month for 500 orders. If the store wants VIP tiers, Smile.io moves to Growth at $199 a month, while Yotpo's tiers need the custom-quoted Premium plan.
For a shop with two locations and an online store, Marsello Loyalty Launch costs $60 a month per site in USD. Counting each location and the website as a site, that is $180 a month, or $2,160 a year, before email marketing at $15 per 1,000 customers or SMS credits.
Restaurants on a POS should compare the add-on cost: Square Plus at $49 a month per location includes loyalty and marketing, SpotOn's All-In plan includes loyalty at $0 per station on a two-year term, and Toast charges loyalty as an add-on on top of $69 a month.
Know the difference: points programs vs VIP tiers
A points program is the simple version: customers earn points for spending, signing up or referring friends, then spend points on discounts, free shipping or free products. It is easy to explain and cheap to run, and every tool here supports it on its entry plan.
A VIP tier program adds status. Customers who spend more move into higher tiers with better earning rates or perks, which gives your best customers a reason to keep their spending with you rather than a competitor. Tiers work best once you have enough repeat customers to fill them, which is why most vendors keep them on higher plans.
Quick comparison: tool type by need
| Buyer | Best pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| New or small online store | Smile.io | Free to 200 orders/month, Essential $15/month |
| Stores using Yotpo reviews | Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals | Reviews earn points, free to 100 orders, Pro $199/month |
| Growing Shopify brands | LoyaltyLion | Built-for-you launch and Klaviyo flows, $199/month |
| Shops with POS and website | Marsello | Shared points across channels, $60/month per site (USD) |
| Shops and cafes on Square | Square | Loyalty and marketing on Plus, $49/month per location |
| Restaurants wanting loyalty included | SpotOn | Loyalty in the $0/station All-In plan |
| Restaurants on Toast | Toast | Loyalty add-on tied to every check |
Mistakes to avoid
- Launching without promoting it. Add the program to receipts, the checkout, emails and the counter, or members never join.
- Making rewards too hard to reach. If the first reward takes a year of buying, customers forget the program exists.
- Ignoring the order caps. A sale weekend can push an order-based plan into overage charges.
- Running separate online and in-store programs. Two balances confuse customers; choose a tool that shares points across channels.
- Never measuring repeat rate. Track repeat purchase rate and revenue from members versus non-members, or you cannot tell if the program pays for itself.
Related comparisons: UGC Platforms · White Label Software Platforms for Agencies · Website Traffic Analysis Tools · Website Design Companies for Small Business
How we chose
We checked each vendor's own pricing page in November 2026 and recorded the starting price as shown, including the currency and billing basis. We ranked the tools for small and mid-sized businesses, giving credit for free or low-cost entry plans, how far each one goes before VIP tiers cost extra, and whether loyalty works across in-store and online sales. Ratings come from G2 pages checked on the dates shown in the sources; we did not verify ratings for the tools that show none. No vendor paid for a place in this list, and none of the links here are affiliate links.
What to do next
Pull your repeat-purchase rate for the last six months, choose one simple reward that costs no more than you can afford on that repeat revenue, and launch it on the free or entry plan of the tool that fits where your customers buy. If repeat customers are covered but new ones are not finding you, book a free SEO review.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best loyalty software?
For online stores, Smile.io is the best start with a free plan up to 200 orders a month and Essential at $15 a month. Yotpo and LoyaltyLion suit larger brands at $199 a month, Marsello suits physical retail from $60 a month per site, and restaurants on Toast or SpotOn should start with the POS's own loyalty.
Is there free loyalty software?
Yes. Smile.io is free up to 200 orders a month, Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals is free up to 100 orders a month, and SpotOn's All-In POS plan includes loyalty at $0 per station on a two-year term.
How much does a loyalty program cost to run?
Software runs from $15 a month on Smile.io Essential to $199 a month on Yotpo Pro or LoyaltyLion Classic. The bigger cost is the rewards themselves, so set the points value so that rewards cost a small, known share of repeat-customer revenue.
What is the difference between loyalty and referral software?
Loyalty software rewards existing customers for repeat purchases and actions; referral software rewards customers for bringing in new ones. Smile.io, Yotpo, LoyaltyLion and Marsello include both, but dedicated referral tools go deeper on the referral side.
Which loyalty software works for in-store and online sales?
Marsello connects POS and ecommerce so points earned in either place share one balance, and LoyaltyLion includes Shopify POS on Classic for a single location and multi-location POS from Advanced.
Do loyalty programs work for small businesses?
They work when the business already has repeat customers and the reward is worth coming back for. A simple points-for-visits or spend-based program inside your POS is usually enough before paying for VIP tiers and referral campaigns.
What does loyalty management software do?
It runs the program for you: customers earn points on purchases, referrals bring in new buyers, and VIP tiers reward the best spenders. Smile.io, Yotpo and LoyaltyLion do this for online stores, with LoyaltyLion adding Klaviyo email flows. Marsello ties points to the POS and online store with Apple and Google Wallet passes, while Square, SpotOn and Toast build loyalty into the till for shops and restaurants.
Sources we checked (11)
- Smile.io — smile.io/pricing (checked November 16, 2026)
- Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals — www.yotpo.com (checked November 5, 2026)
- Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals reviews on G2 (checked November 5, 2026)
- LoyaltyLion — loyaltylion.com/pricing (checked November 16, 2026)
- Marsello — www.marsello.com/pricing (checked November 16, 2026)
- Square — squareup.com/us/en/pricing (checked November 10, 2026)
- Square reviews on G2 (checked November 10, 2026)
- SpotOn — www.spoton.com/pricing (checked November 8, 2026)
- SpotOn reviews on G2 (checked November 8, 2026)
- Toast — pos.toasttab.com/blog/on-the-line/toast-pricing (checked November 8, 2026)
- Toast reviews on G2 (checked November 8, 2026)
Make one of these tools?
We re-check this list every quarter. Send a correction, request a review, or ask about a clearly labeled sponsored spot.
Request a listingFree SEO and AI visibility audit
Find out what is holding your rankings back
Send us your site. Within 2 business days you get a written audit, an AI visibility check and a short fix list ranked by impact. Free, with no contract attached.
Request my free audit→


